JMHO...I would try to use a used, serviceable OEM part.
Other than to make the slight alteration of the sentiment to "exhausted every reasonable avenue," I agree.Aftermarket only if you can't find the original item. And I mean after you have exhausted every avenue for the original item.
It has a costly effect, and though it can be done, it will be awell that is my thinking...i love some of the looks but i always side on originality....