I was that member you were referring to 
I'll start by saying all the watches I'm outlining below are original examples from what I can tell, I have no reason to believe their inserts have been replaced, but I can't 100% say that's true because I'm not the original owner of any of them.
That said, what I have seen from my collection, the net is - for 6105, 6306/6309, 7548, 7C43, 7002 full size divers - '70-early '81(March) have matte bezel inserts, mid '81 (June?) and on, have gloss inserts.
From my examples of 6306/6309-70XX - they are all matte bezel inserts (Dec '77 - March '81)
From my 7548-70XX examples - they are matte bezel inserts (Mar '78-Dec '80), with my June '81 (orange dial) and June '85 (200m dial) examples having gloss bezel inserts
My 7002-70XX examples - they are gloss inserts ('88 - '89) - the pepsi doesn't look like it in the picture, but there is a gloss sheen on it when looking closely. All the 7002's I've owned have gloss inserts.
My 7C43-70XX examples (2 SQ variants since sold) were gloss inserts (Both from '87), and my JDM 7C43-7010 from '91 also has a gloss insert. All the 7C43's I've owned have gloss inserts.
I'll caveat with the usual saying - you never know with Seiko - I'm sure there are outliers, but the above is what I have seen with my collection over the years.
Todd
I'll start by saying all the watches I'm outlining below are original examples from what I can tell, I have no reason to believe their inserts have been replaced, but I can't 100% say that's true because I'm not the original owner of any of them.
That said, what I have seen from my collection, the net is - for 6105, 6306/6309, 7548, 7C43, 7002 full size divers - '70-early '81(March) have matte bezel inserts, mid '81 (June?) and on, have gloss inserts.
From my examples of 6306/6309-70XX - they are all matte bezel inserts (Dec '77 - March '81)

From my 7548-70XX examples - they are matte bezel inserts (Mar '78-Dec '80), with my June '81 (orange dial) and June '85 (200m dial) examples having gloss bezel inserts


My 7002-70XX examples - they are gloss inserts ('88 - '89) - the pepsi doesn't look like it in the picture, but there is a gloss sheen on it when looking closely. All the 7002's I've owned have gloss inserts.

My 7C43-70XX examples (2 SQ variants since sold) were gloss inserts (Both from '87), and my JDM 7C43-7010 from '91 also has a gloss insert. All the 7C43's I've owned have gloss inserts.


I'll caveat with the usual saying - you never know with Seiko - I'm sure there are outliers, but the above is what I have seen with my collection over the years.
Todd